Blog

Online reputation management nightmares: Amy’s Baking Company Debacle

Online reputation management nightmares: Amy’s Baking Company Debacle

Last Updated on August 3, 2023 by Steven W. Giovinco

A look at how one company responded to customers, and made their online reputation worse

How important are reviews? 

Negative ones can be a nightmare, especially for businesses that deal with customers, such as restaurants.

During the taping of Gordon Ramsay’s episode of Kitchen Nightmares, things turned even worse. Amy’s Baking Company and the owner’s online response is one of the best text-book cases of what NOT to do.  Their complete meltdown propelled their online reputation to legendary proportions—negative, that is.

To recap, the British chef Gordon Ramsay for his Fox show visits restaurants in need of a major overhaul, and usually provides harsh, tough but truthful advice.

When he visited Amy’s Baking Company in Scottsdale, Arizona, things quickly got out of hand, and for the first time, Gordon ended the show’s taping because of the owner’s belligerent attacks.

But things end there.  The owner’s response afterwards was oddly disturbing and created an all-out declaration of war. 

Their continual tirades waged on Facebook, logged mostly against customers, as well as others, just made things worse.  (For the record, they said their Facebook account was hacked; another page was created and both were removed.  They plan an reop

What To Do: Be Humble, Professional

This highlights one of the prime objectives of online reputation management: engage with the customer or client politely, professionally. The last thing you want to do is agitate them more, possibly resulting in more negative posts. 

Also, acknowledge the issue, investigate it, and if true, correct the problem.  Most important, communicate this or your findings to the customer or offer a discount for their next purchase.  

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
LinkedIn

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Table of Contents

Free Evaluation

Feel free to reach out at 347-559-4952 or email steve@recoverreputation.com

On Key

Related Posts

Case Study: Fixing Redirect and Indexing Issues to Improve SEO and Online Reputation

Last Updated on November 5, 2024 by Steven W. Giovinco The Problem: Mysterious Redirects and Crawling Issues Affecting Website Visibility What if your web pages don’t show up in Google? Imagine working hard to maintain a site for years, publishing valuable blog posts frequently and providing useful information to readers/clients. One day it seems you

MrBeast’s Challenges: A Case Study in Online Reputation Management

Last Updated on October 21, 2024 by Steven W. Giovinco Introduction MrBeast is a digital phenomenon–you might have heard of him or seen some of his videos. With 320 million subscribers, his influence is massive, going beyond the online realm into restaurants, philanthropy, branding, and merchandise, etc.  But the massive rise has recently come with

Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top